I was reading a collection of writings from Isreal and I could not help but think of a classroom debate that I had in the fifth grade and how even then, the unmistakeable signs that define left from right, and right from wrong in the eyes of the beholder; even at age 10.
We were studying Geography, and Iraq, Iran and Israel came up. At this point, we had only learned of Africa; the Lower and western regions that African American’s, (Blacks) and when Iran, Iraq and Israel were explained to us; we then had to split up into two debate teams and debate the following.
Group A had lived in a country for thousands of years. Then Group A left, and Group B moved in.
A Thousand years later, Group A came back and demanded that group A had to leave.
Group A demanded that group B leave and Group B demanded that Group A leave.
They could not live together and both felt it was their land.
…Almost all of the classroom declared that Group B should leave.
I argued that Group B shouldn’t have to leave because it isn’t group B’s fault that Group A left, nor was it Group B’s fault that group A came back and it wasn’t justified to say that Group B had to suddenly leave thier home that they had lived in for a thousand years, and now it was just as much thier home as group A’s. I then said that Group A shouldn’t have to leave either, but if they absolutely refused to get along and group B was willing to, than it really should be group A that had to leave, since they were the ones refusing to share and had no right to demand something back; but I felt they should both be able to stay and just accept that they were different.
I was one of the only ones who argued this point; unable to see how everyone else, including the teacher could accept that group A should just get the land back. I fet that if group A couldn’t tolerate group B, that group A should have to leave. I also felt that if group B was the one being intolerant, than they really shouldn’t have any right to complain since it was Group A’s land in the first place…and if anything, they should have a common bond in that they were both driven away from thier homelands to begin with.
I didn’t really convince anyone else, but I remembered being confused at the end of the day.
It made sense to me as a child…what should it matter what we believe, as long as we remember that we are all human beings? Why did people feel they had to have it thier way or no way? Why couldn’t they share? Why couldn’t they compromise…or why couldn’t they at least be tolerant of someone’s right to exist as they are?
I realize there are religious fanatics out there of all sorts who would flip out and start screaming about righteousness, but the sad thing is, I’m not even that religious and even -I- understand that god does not ask us to kill in his name.
God does not condemn us showing compassion to our enemy, and god does not codemn us for showing tolerance in the face of intolerance. God only asks that we live our lives in a certain way…and this is true of almost all of the gods that I have studied.
Never does it say anywhere that god is pleased when there was death…only life.
Never does it say anywhere that god is pleased when we murder in his name…in fact, nearly all of the gods I have researched ask that we respect life and that the greatest sin we could commit is to kill in his name.
God is not a murderer. So, why then, can’t anyone else seem to remember this?
I have a theory for that too.
There was a clear and solid ‘right and wrong’ in our eyes when my class had learned of slavery; the conclusion being of course that it was a horrible thing to have done to another human being.
When we had learned about slavery in fourth grade, I had then in return, remembered with distinction the discomfort of our teacher trying to explain our American History…glossing over that we massacerred thousands of indians in order to justify our own wants for what they had and what we wanted. No one wants to acknowledege that the first “Americans” to America were murderers. No one wants to be the bad guy, and so we glorify ourselves so that it looks as if we were justified to do the horrible things that we did. That’s what all of this war is really about…making someone else the bad guy.
And that’s the real truth.
It doesn’t matter what you call yourself. Republican, Freedom Fighter, Baptist, Athiest, Christian, Jew or Muslim. When you justify striking down another human being so that they can’t disagree with you about what you are, or what you think is right…you are a failure. A punch, A word, A gun, A bomb; If you cannot stand face to face with someone who would dare to believe something different than you and still see them as another human being; you are a failure.
It makes my soul ache to know there is that much hate in this world.
Because I look at you, and I see someone who lives, breaths, thinks and wonders; I see life…despite the monster of hate that lurks beneath your eyes. Ther was once, when the hate did not consume you…
When the hate did not consume all of us.
but then we grew up; and became stupid.
…So desperate to not have our children point out that the emperor has no cloths on; we’ve taken to brainwashing thier innocent minds early; disguising the truth in stories designed to make them believe one side is right and the other side is monsters.
…I say, that in god’s eyes, we continue to fail.
After all; we can’t even admit our own mistakes.